WASHINGTON — Quickly after he undercut President Trump’s baseless claims of widespread voter fraud in early December, Lawyer Common William P. Barr’s time atop the Justice Division hurtled to its finish. The president and his allies attacked Mr. Barr in private and non-private, making clear that he ought to retract his evaluation or spend the final weeks of the administration belittled and probably fired in humiliating vogue.
Mr. Barr started working on a face-saving exit plan, in line with individuals conversant in his efforts. He and allies started back-channel communications with the White Home to gauge his probabilities at an amicable parting, and he spent a weekend writing a letter that will announce his departure whereas preserving his relationship with the president.
The hassle succeeded in allowing Mr. Barr to leave largely on his phrases. Mr. Trump heaped reward on Mr. Barr in saying his exit, and the lawyer basic returned the favor, blurring the truth that he had been all however pushed out.
The orchestrated farewell was a mirrored image of how Mr. Barr navigated his tenure operating a Justice Division for a president who seen it as hostile towards him. Mr. Barr’s time was largely outlined by the notion that he set aside the department’s independence to advance the president’s political and private pursuits, mainly by undermining its personal investigation into Russia and the Trump marketing campaign and by wading into marketing campaign points, together with taking part in up fears of voter fraud.
However Mr. Barr additionally confirmed flashes of autonomy on the finish of his tenure. His reversal on voter fraud broke from the president. He mentioned he saw no need for a particular counsel to analyze President-elect Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s son Hunter as Mr. Trump clamored for one. And Mr. Barr even acknowledged that a few of his suspicions in regards to the Obama administration’s examination of Russian election interference have been misguided.
Historians will debate whether or not Mr. Barr, 70, was making an attempt to protect his status. Already a polarizing determine, he had confronted a brand new groundswell of criticism in current weeks for alleviating restrictions on election-related investigations as Mr. Trump ramped up his complaints about voting irregularities and for making certain that the division’s examination of the Russia investigation continues into the Biden administration.
Mr. Barr’s allies say he merely adopted his instincts, honed by his maximalist view of govt energy, and was untroubled by perceptions that he was serving Mr. Trump’s private agenda.
Both manner, an examination of Mr. Barr’s tenure, primarily based on interviews with allies, critics, present and former regulation enforcement officers and lecturers, exhibits that it doesn’t matter what Mr. Barr says or does, Mr. Trump will in the end outline his legacy as lawyer basic.
“Invoice Barr might be inexorably tied to Donald Trump,” mentioned Nancy Baker, a political scientist who research attorneys basic and interviewed Mr. Barr for an oral historical past undertaking by the Miller Middle on the College of Virginia. Whereas administration critics credited Mr. Barr for refuting Mr. Trump’s false election assertions, in the end, she mentioned, “he’ll at all times be Trump’s man.”
Mr. Barr, who left the job final week, mentioned at his remaining information convention that he accepted the submit as a result of he felt he may assist the division throughout a fraught interval.
“I knew I used to be signing up for a tough project on this division. As I’ve mentioned, there have been tough occasions,” mentioned Mr. Barr, who declined to reply questions for this text. “I don’t remorse coming in as a result of I believe it’s at all times an honor to serve the nation.”
When Mr. Barr, who had been lawyer basic in the course of the first Bush administration, returned to the workplace early final 12 months, some Trump critics seen his expertise as a possible test on the president. However his personal document confirmed that Mr. Barr regarded presidential power as broad, and Mr. Trump provided an opportunity to revive what Mr. Barr noticed as govt authority misplaced within the post-Watergate period.
“As a cupboard member, the lawyer basic was supportive of the administration and plenty of of its priorities. He was unfairly criticized for that,” mentioned Brian Rabbitt, his former chief of workers and the outgoing head of the Justice Division’s felony division. “However you don’t take a job like his to withstand. You’re taking the job to assist the administration do its greatest for the nation.”
Mr. Barr was captivated with points together with increasing non secular freedoms and supporting Native American reservations and tribal regulation enforcement workplaces, former colleagues mentioned, and he largely continued his Bush-era combat in opposition to medicine, violent crime and what he deemed to be politically motivated prosecutions.
That work was eclipsed by the Russia investigation, which each he and Mr. Trump believed represented an abuse of energy by the F.B.I.
“He had a vigilante angle towards the Russia investigation — ‘I alone will repair this,’” mentioned Rebecca Roiphe, a professor at New York Legislation Faculty who research the historical past and ethics of the authorized career.
After his February 2019 affirmation, Mr. Barr launched into what division officers mentioned was a single-minded mission to reveal any wrongdoing by investigators.
Mr. Barr started by reshaping the public’s perception of essentially the most politically charged investigation in a technology in the absolute best mild for Mr. Trump. He went on to border it as a political cudgel used to “sabotage” Mr. Trump’s presidency, even after the Justice Division’s inspector basic concluded in any other case. “Prosecutors can typically change into headhunters, consumed with taking down their goal,” Mr. Barr said this fall. He said in his remaining days in workplace that the investigators for the particular counsel, Robert S. Mueller III, have been too biased to reveal F.B.I. wrongdoing.
Mr. Barr went past discuss, tapping John H. Durham, the U.S. lawyer in Connecticut, to open a felony investigation into the origins of the Russia inquiry. Mr. Barr talked up Mr. Durham’s work within the months earlier than the election, flouting Justice Division norms to keep away from publicly discussing ongoing felony investigations as Mr. Trump promoted the inquiry as sure to show a “deep state” plot in opposition to him.
“He had a blind spot on Russia,” Ms. Baker mentioned of Mr. Barr. “Blind to the truth that he acted politically in his remedy of the Russia investigation, even when in his thoughts he acted out of his perception that his actions have been in line with the rule of regulation.”
After the election, amid a storm of complaints from Mr. Trump’s allies that Mr. Durham had not revealed info that might have helped the president, Mr. Barr downplayed expectations that he would expose felony acts. He told a Wall Street Journal opinion columnist that by focusing solely on indictments, the political class excuses different contemptible habits.
And although in the identical interview he backed off his suspicions of the C.I.A.’s examination of Russian election interference in 2016, he additionally confirmed Mr. Durham was nonetheless reviewing the 2017 intelligence group evaluation about Russian election interference.
Contained in the Justice Division, the turning level got here with Mr. Barr’s interventions in two high-profile instances stemming from the Russia inquiry, these of Mr. Trump’s longtime good friend Roger J. Stone Jr. and his former nationwide safety adviser Michael T. Flynn. Some prosecutors withdrew from the instances. A couple of left the division fully. A sometimes discreet work pressure started to call for Mr. Barr’s resignation and accuse him of turning the division “right into a shield to protect the president” and a device for Mr. Trump to settle political scores.
Mr. Barr rebuffed these allegations, publicly rebuking Mr. Trump for opining on the Stone case. Former aides mentioned Mr. Barr was conveying the message to each Mr. Trump and federal prosecutors that he acts primarily based on his convictions, not politics.
However Mr. Barr’s interventions in ways in which benefited Mr. Trump prolonged past the particular counsel investigation. Inspecting Mr. Trump’s dealings with Ukraine that prompted impeachment, the Justice Division shortly decided he had not dedicated a marketing campaign finance crime, properly earlier than the president’s broad efforts to stress Kyiv got here into focus.
The division additionally took on lawsuits over books written by Trump adversaries. Within the case of the previous nationwide safety adviser John R. Bolton, who had fallen out of Mr. Trump’s favor, it opened a criminal inquiry into whether or not he illegally disclosed labeled info.
Being a profitable lawyer basic “is not only about doing the fitting factor, it’s about preserving the legitimacy of the establishment,” Ms. Roiphe mentioned. “Even when he actually held these beliefs, he addressed them in ways in which have been solely revered by his personal political followers.”
Some Justice Division officers believed that Mr. Barr privately honed the president’s perception that his lawyer basic was his political fixer and used that capital with Mr. Trump to guard the division, shielding it from blowback when it prosecuted instances that interfered in commerce negotiations with China and to guard the F.B.I. director, Christopher A. Wray, from being fired over the president’s animosity towards the bureau.
Buffeted by assault, Mr. Barr stored an unusually small interior circle of aides and relied on them, relatively than the heads of the division’s divisions, for recommendation, in line with former officers.
Mr. Barr appeared to scorn enter from elsewhere within the division, notably from the profession workers, as pointless noise that slowed down his quick deliberative course of, former officers mentioned.
Mr. Barr made his low opinion clear in a speech this 12 months, saying that no profitable organizations deemed choices by low-level workers “sacrosanct” or deferred to “no matter these subordinates wish to do.”
However he appeared blindsided by a string of miscues earlier this 12 months, mainly his management of the federal response to this 12 months’s nationwide protests over racial injustice. Mr. Barr got here underneath hearth for ordering federal officers to clear a park close to the White Home in June simply earlier than Mr. Trump’s widely criticized photo op exterior a church. Irritating some within the White Home, he additionally contradicted Mr. Trump’s rationalization for sheltering in a bunker throughout protests.
And later that month, Mr. Trump distanced himself nearly instantly from Mr. Barr’s dismissal of the highest federal prosecutor in Manhattan.
In his remaining weeks, Mr. Barr started to see Mr. Trump’s agenda, which he supported, as separate from the president himself and his private shortcomings, like his refusal to simply accept the outcomes of the election, associates mentioned.
Mr. Barr accepted Mr. Biden’s win and mentioned no quantity of fraud he had seen would overturn it. He had already resisted Mr. Trump’s stress late within the marketing campaign to prosecute Democrats.
He additionally stored quiet the possibly explosive information that Hunter Biden was under criminal investigation. Disclosing that, associates mentioned, may have undermined a future Biden presidency, an act Mr. Barr noticed as a possible echo of the investigation opened 4 years earlier into Mr. Trump.